Introduction
The educational historian Harold Silver once described the relationship between historians and policy analysis as being one akin to that of a British chef in Paris. The epithet is particularly apt for school meals, where history and policy have rarely converged, and usually even then with somewhat unpalatable results. Historical appraisals of school meals policy for policy purposes have been rare, and on those occasions when they have been attempted they have generally been limited and partial in their purview. A critical appraisal of the history of the School Meals Service (SMS) as a whole is necessary for a fully effective contribution to future policy development in this area (previous overviews include a History & Policy paper on the subject).
This paper sets out to review the connections between current school meals policy and its history in the UK. First we analyse the different types of relationship that have been drawn between the policy and the history, secondly we develop a specific example of how current policy developments have treated a previous initiative of 2004-2005, and finally we review briefly, how the policy has been interpreted in school practice and in public discourse.
1. History as policy?
In the US, Elizabeth Hansot and David Tyack pointed out in the 1980s the importance of education policy embracing what they called a ‘usable past’. By this, they meant that policy-makers had a historical consciousness whether they were aware of it or not; the point was how to frame this: ‘The issue is not whether people use a sense of the past in shaping their lives but how accurate that historical map is.’ They went on to argue that history could potentially mitigate against a contemporary tendency in education policy towards fragmentation, privatism and a preoccupation with fixing immediate problems rather than considering more fundamental and underlying issues: ‘Perhaps historians, habitually backward-looking, will be able to help policy makers in education not only to use a sense of the past (which they do, willy-nilly), but also to make sense of it.’
There have been broadly three key phases which school meal provision has undergone since its origins in England and Wales in 1906, soon followed by Scotland. The first is the period from the Education (Provision of Meals) Act of 1906, which permitted – though it did not enforce – the provision of school meals, to the Education Act of 1944, which made provision of school meals mandatory with free school meals available for those in need. The second is from 1944 to the Education Act of 1980, often viewed as the golden age of the SMS, which provided a national system of school meal provision supported by the State. Third is the period since 1980, which has seen the development of a marketized service, once again the responsibility of local authorities with schools themselves accountable for providing an appropriate service for their pupils. In each of these phases, the operation of school meals was based on a distinctive legal framework, with its own aims and priorities.
This history is therefore not a story of gradual progress but one of distinct phases, each of which represented both opportunities and challenges. This has amounted to a potential service for the national community and its children that has been only partially realised.
Since the beginning of the current century, school meals have been a controversial public issue, with periodic attempts made by different governments to improve or expand provision. Public debate has frequently invoked the history of school meals, but often selectively, drawing on comparisons with Victorian deprivation or nostalgia for an imagined golden age rather than sustained engagement with the historical development of the service. For example, in 2015, the NASUWT teachers’ union, in protesting against the consequences of poor housing and poverty, equated current provision with that of the Victorian era in the nineteenth century. According to a BBC report, ‘Teachers say they are seeing “Victorian conditions” with pupils arriving at school hungry and not wearing the right clothes needed for the weather.’
Other public commentary has been nostalgic for an earlier golden age or for perceived heroes and heroines of a bygone age in pioneering provision. For instance, in 2024 the food policy NGO Nourish Scotland issued a report calling for the return of public diners such as had been developed during the Second World War under Winston Churchill as prime minister. The BBC report on this Scottish initiative asked rhetorically: ‘Could taxpayer-funded public diners be revived?
Recent reviews of the policy experience of school meals have been very limited in their understanding of the history that has led to the current situation. When they have attempted to take some account of this history, they have made use only of their own personal and professional memories, allied to the ‘nostalgic power’ of school meals themselves. This is in line with other policy developments since the 1980s, which have had a frequent tendency to emphasise particular policy problems as they arise rather than underlying historical issues, and relying on personal experience and memories rather than having recourse to a public record of the past.
In the 1940s and 1950s, as mass State provision of school meals became established, efforts were made by policy makers and practitioners to ingrain a critical understanding of the history within further policy developments. One instance of this was that of the Labour MP for Bradford East, Frank McLeavy, in a House of Commons debate on school meals in April 1949. McLeavy noted the early origins of the SMS and the central role of Bradford in its beginnings:
I, personally, have occasion to feel some measure of satisfaction, and indeed pride, because the local authority of the city of Bradford was the first in Britain to assume, in 1904, public responsibility for the feeding of necessitous children. This decision caused a nation-wide consciousness; public opinion was aroused; and it resulted in the passing, in 1906, of the first Act of Parliament dealing with this question, which extended the Bradford scheme to the whole of the country.
This speech was one of many public contributions of the time that created a public history of school meals, encompassing the full record of the service since 1906, and giving recommendations for the future that were taken up by the then Labour government. It provided a relatively brief treatment that stressed a particular viewpoint on current issues, and offered a far from inclusive view of school meals and their benefits. Nevertheless, it did give purchase to historical issues that informed the contemporary policy debate around school meals.
2. Learning from the past
The current Labour Government has announced major reforms to the School Food Standards, promising that ‘tastier school dinners will be on the menu for millions of children across the country’ as part of ‘the biggest overhaul of school food in a generation’. The new standards will require more fresh fruit and vegetables, fibre-rich foods and balanced meals intended to help children remain ‘focused, energised and ready to learn throughout the school day’. Schools will be expected to publish their food policies and menus online and nominate a school food governor. The Government has also promised training, resources and guidance, with the Department for Education working alongside the Food Standards Agency to develop an approach to monitoring. The standards will come into force in September 2027.
This is welcome and encouraging news for supporters of improved school-meal provision, although it does not introduce universal free school meals of the kind now available in some parts of the UK. It comes more than twenty years after an earlier Labour government, under the then prime minister Tony Blair, made a comparable commitment to improve school food. New statutory standards were introduced, but the broader transformation of provision was neither fully realised nor consistently sustained by successive governments.
Recent history is often disregarded as irrelevant to current concerns. The temptation is familiar: all this happened before the present government took office; that was then, this is now. Yet school-food policy is cumulative. Decisions about kitchens, staffing, contracts, oversight and entitlement continue to shape what later governments can achieve. As the television chef Jamie Oliver, who helped to initiate the school meals campaign over twenty years ago, himself remarks, ‘it is so important to remember where we started from’.
Two questions should therefore be raised. First, why did the commitments of 2005 fail to produce comprehensive and lasting change across schools? Second, can the present Government learn from that experience and from the warnings made at the time?
In early 2005, Jamie Oliver made an immediate impact on national debate through his Channel 4 series ‘Jamie’s School Dinners’. He presented a vivid picture of poor nutritional standards, with turkey twizzlers becoming instantly notorious. At one secondary school featured in the programme, pupils were reported to consume a quarter of a ton of chips each week.
Following this, an independent School Meals Review Panel was established. Its 26 members represented a wide range of groups and organisations with direct experience of school-food provision. Drawing on a survey of 5,695 pupils across 79 secondary schools in England, it found that fewer than half of the schools were meeting the existing nutritional standards. Fruit, fruit juice, vegetables and salads were among the least popular choices, while only one-quarter of head chefs and catering managers had received training in healthy eating and cooking during the previous twelve months.
The panel’s final report, ‘Turning the Tables’, was published in September 2005 and offered a damning assessment of the existing system. It traced current problems partly to the long-term consequences of policy changes beginning with the Education Act 1980. Thirteen per cent of schools had no kitchen facilities; in some of these, pupils entitled to free school meals received only sandwiches. The report also noted that one in five boys and one in four girls were overweight or obese. Compulsory competitive tendering, introduced later in the 1980s, had operated on the principle that the ‘lowest bid wins’, putting ‘economy above quality in provision of the service’.
The report was presented to the then secretary of state, Ruth Kelly, who announced at the Labour Party annual conference that ‘junk foods’ would be banned from schools. Poor-quality processed ‘bangers and burgers’ would no longer be served. Ofsted inspectors would help monitor the standards of food served in schools and review how cooking was taught, with the aim of improving young people’s culinary skills.
The plans were quickly endorsed by the Conservative shadow education secretary, David Cameron, later prime minister from 2010 to 2016. Cameron also criticised the Government’s ‘belated U-turn’ and complained that it had previously ignored Conservative proposals to ban junk food from schools. More importantly, he warned that tighter standards required ‘sufficient resources for schools to provide the extra staff and kitchen facilities required – two crucial elements which are not being met in many schools’.
There were clear warnings about the obstacles ahead. Headteachers questioned whether schools had the capacity to enact the fundamental and costly changes required. They also warned that building contracts for schools without kitchens would undermine promises to provide healthy cooked meals.
The chair of the review panel, Suzi Leather, expressed confidence that its recommendations would help establish a ‘world-class school meals service’. One of the panel’s principal recommendations was the creation of a School Food Trust to support implementation in schools.
The Trust was duly established with £15 million of government funding. Its extensive remit included advising on school-food standards, supporting implementation, overcoming practical barriers, increasing pupil uptake, improving training for catering staff, engaging parents, assessing costs and benefits, working with Ofsted to measure progress, and improving children’s cooking skills and food knowledge.
In 2010, Cameron’s incoming Coalition Government announced the withdrawal of central funding from the School Food Trust as part of its wider programme of reducing arm’s-length public bodies. The organisation continued independently as the Children’s Food Trust before closing in 2017. [shouldn’t you also say something about Cameron’s delivery – or not – on his ‘sufficient resources for schools to provide the extra staff and kitchen facilities required – two crucial elements. The Coalition Government did subsequently invest in school food infrastructure, particularly through the introduction of universal infant free school meals in 2014. This included £150 million of capital funding for kitchen and dining facilities in 2014–15, followed by further investment. Nevertheless, this funding was directed principally towards implementing the new entitlement for infant pupils, rather than addressing the wider staffing and infrastructure needs of the School Meals Service.
That was then, and this is now. Yet many of the underlying issues remain unresolved. The monitoring role anticipated for Ofsted did not become a durable mechanism for ensuring compliance across schools. The present proposals again promise monitoring, this time involving the Department for Education and the Food Standards Agency, but the details have yet to be established.
Encouragingly, the new proposals acknowledge some of the earlier lessons by promising training, clearer responsibility within schools, published menus and new monitoring arrangements. But history shows that standards alone are not enough. Reform also requires adequate and continuing funding, kitchens and equipment, a skilled and properly supported workforce, robust monitoring, and institutional capacity capable of sustaining change beyond a single political moment.
The jury is therefore still out. In the interests of the current generation of pupils, will the present Government learn from and improve upon the experience of the past? It now has the opportunity to do so. For now, in relation to the reforms attempted twenty years ago, the verdict must be: ‘Must do better.’
3. Policy and practice
Legislation and official reports reveal the aims and administrative structures of the School Meals Service, but they tell us much less about how policy was experienced by children and by the adults responsible for feeding them. To address this gap, our research combined archival investigation with more than 50 new oral-history interviews involving over 70 former pupils, parents, teachers and catering staff. We also drew upon existing oral-history collections, memoirs and autobiographies, alongside contemporary ethnographic research in schools.
These sources demonstrate why the implementation of policy matters as much as its formal design. School meals were experienced through the senses and emotions: the smell of food travelling along school corridors, the clatter and noise of the dining hall, the texture of particular dishes, the authority of supervising adults, and the social rituals of eating alongside other children. Such experiences could create feelings of care, security and belonging. They could also produce anxiety, humiliation and resistance.
This is particularly apparent in memories of free school meals. Policymakers were aware by the 1960s that fear of identification discouraged eligible families from claiming them. In 1966, research for the Ministry of National Insurance indicated that only around half of eligible children were receiving free meals. Official guidance subsequently urged local authorities to avoid arrangements that publicly distinguished recipients. Nevertheless, identifying practices, including differently coloured tickets, separate queues and the public calling of names, continued for decades.
One participant, Jim, who attended school in Bradford in the late 1950s and early 60s, recalled receiving free meals temporarily when his father was unable to work. His ticket carried the words “admit one free meal” prominently. He volunteered to collect the tickets for his whole table so that he could conceal his own among them, but another boy discovered it and called out: “Who’s got the free meal then?” Jim still described this, some sixty years later, as an “excruciatingly embarrassing experience.”
Women interviewed together in Glasgow remembered teachers calling children forward to receive their free-meal tickets in the 1950s. One described the command as “come out the frees”; another remembered the resulting journey across the classroom simply as “the walk of shame.” Similar forms of public identification were recalled by pupils attending school in the 1980s and early 1990s.
These accounts matter for present policy because they show that stigma did not arise solely from eligibility rules. It was produced through ordinary administrative practices inside schools. Cashless payments and online ordering have removed some visible distinctions, but targeted provision continues to carry the possibility of identification. Historically, attempts to preserve confidentiality repeatedly mitigated stigma without removing its underlying source. The evidence therefore strengthens the case for universal provision, through which receiving a school meal becomes an ordinary entitlement rather than a visible indication of family poverty.
Oral testimony also reveals experiences easily overlooked by policies centred principally upon nutrition. Neurodivergent participants described dining halls as environments of intense noise, smell, movement and social pressure. Some recalled being forced to eat foods whose textures they found intolerable or leaving the dining hall early – and consequently eating too little – to escape sensory overload. Their experiences suggest that providing a nutritionally balanced meal is not sufficient if the physical and disciplinary environment prevents a child from eating it.
A historically informed school-food policy must therefore attend not only to what is placed on the plate but to the conditions under which it is served and eaten. Dining spaces, queuing and payment systems, the time allowed for lunch, staff practices, sensory accessibility and opportunities for children to exercise meaningful choice are all integral parts of provision. The history of school meals shows that policies succeed or fail in the everyday encounter between the service and the child.
Historical and ethnographic evidence together show why the gap between providing a school meal and a child actually eating it matters. Across successive reforms, the conditions in which meals are prepared, served and eaten have shaped whether improved provision translates into children’s consumption and experience. Oral histories reveal recurring obstacles, while contemporary school ethnography helps identify how these operate in practice today.
4. Conclusions
What then is the potential policy value of this fuller historical understanding – combining the record of legislation and administration with lived experience and public memory?
This should enable us not only to attend to immediate issues in improving or expanding school food provision, such as are being currently developed by the UK Government. They should help to remind us of the longstanding issues underlying school meals, such as the stigma attached to selective provision of free school meals which itself originated with the charitable provision of the nineteenth century.
It should also enable the possibility of not only improving provision but also reimagining school food for the future, by engaging in a critical way with ideas and practices that have been developed at different times over the past century. This is not to go back to the past, but to learn from both the promise and the disappointments of this historical experience. These include the problems as well as the benefits of, for example, school breakfasts, the idea of a whole school approach, the role of school gardening, and the possibilities of food education through schools. Such issues deserve detailed examination in their own right as part of a fuller development of reimagining school food for the future.
This is what David Tyack and others in the USA have described as a ‘usable past’. This is not only to develop a clear vision of history that can inform our present and future policies. Drawing back the enfolding veils on the past that allow both policy amnesia and social amnesia to take hold, it is also to remember the many ways in which nations can resist and reset individualism and privatism to establish greater civic awareness. Periodic campaigns have repeatedly brought school food back into the public eye. Reform movements in the early twentieth century, wartime nutrition programmes, and more recent interventions by public figures such as Jamie Oliver and Marcus Rashford and charities have all attempted to reshape the system. These moments reveal how school meals occupy a unique position in public debate. They are at once an educational issue, a welfare question, a public health concern and a cultural symbol of the nation’s responsibilities to children.
In the present, policy debates about universalism, means-testing, obesity and budgets continue to swirl. Yet still, the history of the SMS suggests that three principles might help us think differently about the future. First, food is part of education, not a break from it. Wartime reformers and advocates like Le Gros Clark understood this clearly. School meals can support concentration, social learning, and long-term food literacy, but only if they are planned and funded as an educational resource, not an optional extra. Second, children’s voices are not a luxury item; they are essential. Our interviews with pupils, from those complaining about floury cheese and unseasoned chips to those worrying about portion sizes, show that they are sophisticated observers of their own needs. A service designed for children but rarely with them will always be unstable.
And third, ultimately, labour and dignity matter. Dinner ladies, cooks and catering managers have carried this service for decades, often on low pay and precarious contracts. Their accounts of being “put on the back foot” by compulsory competitive tendering, or feeling their skills reduced to opening tins and reheating processed food, tell us what is lost when market logic and its profit-making cost-cutting takes over. Any attempt to rebuild a more just SMS must take their expertise and working conditions seriously. If there is a hopeful note in this history, it lies in the moments when schools, staff, families and children have managed to create something more than a queue and a plate: when meals have become a shared social ritual, a space where children can be fed, seen and heard.
As the revised School Food Standards are implemented, policymakers should assess not only whether meals meet nutritional requirements, but whether children are able and willing to eat them. A practical review should combine measures of uptake and food waste with children’s accounts of mealtimes and an audit of kitchen staffing, dining conditions, time available to eat and sensory accessibility. Historical evidence can help identify recurrent barriers and avoid repeating earlier implementation failures, while ethnographic evidence can test how these barriers operate in present-day schools.
Whether we move closer to that vision may still demand a contribution from campaigns and campaigners such as those that have served the cause of school food, and against child hunger, so often in the past. It will depend no less on the everyday choices we make about what school food is for: a minimal service to keep children going, or a collective commitment to nourishing their bodies, their learning, and their sense of belonging. This will require a resolution of whether governments are willing to treat school meals not as a marginal cost, but as part of a serious strategy to reduce child poverty and inequality. The history of the School Meals Service therefore reminds us that school food has never been a marginal aspect of education policy, but has been, and continues to be, a revealing lens through which to understand how British society has imagined childhood, welfare and the responsibilities of the State.
Such are the issues involved in the idea of a ‘usable past’ for school food in the manner of Hansot and Tyack in the US. It may be, after all, that British chefs have something to bring to the school meals party – even in Paris.