Introduction
In July 2026, as part of a new ESRC-funded research programme, we screened two archival broadcasts about maternity and early motherhood in the 1970s. The first was ‘A Time to be Born’, a 1974 episode of BBC Horizon exploring rising induction rates. The second was a 1978 episode of After Noon, featuring sociologist Ann Oakley alongside two of the participants from her Becoming a Mother study, which explored women’s transition to first-time motherhood. Open to the public, the screening attracted an audience that included academics, practising and retired midwives and obstetricians, as well as participants in Oakley’s study and their families.
Although the screening aimed to explore motherhood in the 1970s, conversation quickly turned to the current maternity crisis. This prompted us to consider how looking back can help us understand the challenges facing maternity services today.
Maternity care and childbirth in the 1970s
In the 1970s, maternity services were undergoing significant changes in the organisation and experience of childbirth. Historians and sociologists have examined this period in terms of continued medicalisation of childbirth and the persistence of medical paternalism. One example, explored in ‘A Time to be Born’, was the rapid increase in the use of synthetic oxytocin to induce labour highlighting that ‘for thousands of women, the experience of giving birth has been totally changed.’
Growing induction rates reflected wider changes in maternity care, in which the roles of obstetricians, midwives and mothers were actively renegotiated (a significant preoccupation for feminist scholars of the time). As birth shifted from home to hospital following the 1970 Peel Report, the timing of labour was increasingly shaped by hospital routines and doctor’s schedules. Supporters of the policy argued that greater control over the timing and location of birth offered practical advantages. Others saw it as opening the door to a wider range of non-essential interventions.
Both hospital births and induction were justified as measures to improve safety, although these claims were challenged. In November 1974 – in response to the Horizon episode – editors of The Lancet called for a ‘reappraisal of the grounds for induction’, questioning whether interventions were always necessary, and distinguishing ‘major obstetric complications’ from social or medical convenience. Others similarly questioned the assumption that hospital birth was inherently safer than homebirth.
While ‘A Time to be Born’ examined the medical management of childbirth, After Noon explored how medicalised care and institutional practices shaped women’s experiences of birth and early motherhood. Together, the two broadcasts revealed a central tension: maternity services were increasingly organised around doctors and institutional routines, while women’s voices risked being overlooked.
From paternalism to partnership?
As discussions unfolded, audience Q&A repeatedly returned to the current maternity crisis, drawing parallels between historical debates and the findings from a 10-year series of reports from Kirkup (2015) to Amos (2026). As one audience member commented: ‘look where we are now. I mean, I don’t see much improvement […] it seems to me we’re going backwards.’
However, the comparison reveals bothcontinuity and change. While concerns about interventions and women’s experiences persist, the way decisions are understood and justified has evolved, most notably in relation to how patients are understood within the decision-making process.
Take, for example, the discussion surrounding the management of latent labour in the Ockenden Report (2026). The report discusses the difficulties for healthcare professionals (HCPs) in deciding whether to advise intervention if labour is not progressing as expected. HCPs must quickly balance the risk of unnecessary early intervention against the potentially life-threatening consequences of delayed action, at the same time including the patient in the decision-making process. This is a far cry from the paternalism of the 1970s where women were not included in such discussions about their care. Today, doctors and patients recognise their transformed roles in decision-making which can result in an uneasy tension. This raises broader questions: how are decisions made, and how are responsibilities shared between HCPs and pregnant people?
Over the intervening decades, maternity care increasingly embraced partnership between women and HCPs. This was reflected in the Changing Childbirth report (1993), which championed woman-centred care through its principles of continuity, choice, and control (the three Cs). The report drew evidence from consumer groups such as NCT and AIMs, midwives, policymakers and doctors, recognising women’s experiences as an important contribution to maternity care reform. This marked a shift from treating women as passive recipients of care towards involving them as active partners in decisions about birth. However, as Tania McIntosh notes, the report’s ambitions did not adequately account for the financial and practical implications on services. Continuity, choice, and control were mapped onto maternity services, implying that continuity of care was achievable, and that mothers could have choice and control in a situation that may be ultimately constrained.
These tensions are particularly apparent in decisions about the progression of labour. Pregnant people may have firm ideas about how they want to give birth, which cannot always be fulfilled. This does not mean that patient preferences are unimportant. Working in partnership requires more than offering patients an illusion of choice: it means negotiating decisions transparently, respecting individual priorities, and acknowledging professional responsibilities.
What has changed – and what remains unresolved?
The past fifty years tell neither a simple story of progress nor stagnation. Expectations of maternity care have changed, with a move away from paternalism towards greater partnership. However, putting these principles into practice remains a challenge.
What does meaningful partnership look like when clinical judgement, personal preferences and service constraints come into tension? And what would maternity services need to change to make that partnership possible? We must address these questions to avoid facing the same challenges in fifty years’ time.