Larissa Kraft
Home / Opinion Articles / In 2026, the British Should Resist the Temptation to ‘Lead’

In recent speeches at the Lord Mayor’s Banquet and in the House of Commons, Prime Minister Andy Burnham invoked the idea of Britain as a leading power in world affairs. He claimed that British leadership by the example of fair play, democracy and a clear sense of right and wrong could contribute to building the ‘greater goodwill […] around the world’ and thus secure British interests in the long term.

The Prime Minister’s determination to continue the reset of the post-Brexit UK-EU relationship is commendable. Nevertheless, going into the negotiations with the EU leaders at the summit meeting this Friday with the aspiration to re-establish British leadership seems an antiquated concept.

In his speech, Burnham echoed his predecessor Winston Churchill’s vision for Britain in the world. After the Second World War, Churchill saw Britain at the centre of three circles of influence: the Commonwealth, the Anglophone world and a united Europe. Yet, it is precisely this conception and self-image of Britain as a ‘special’ power that has so often led its European neighbours to question whether Britain truly was committed to European integration.

Even as Churchill dreamt of the three circles, they were fragile: In the 1950s, Britain quickly lost influence in the rapidly decolonising world, its influence on US politics declined, and the newly formed EEC turned out to be more successful than British leaders had expected. Just a few years later, Churchill’s successor, Harold Macmillan, was forced to admit that the British claim to leadership via the three circles was in disarray. In his ‘Grand Design’ memorandum in the winter of 1960–61, he claimed that, despite ‘all her experience’, the UK no longer had either the economic or the military power ‘to take the leading role’. For Macmillan, this realisation was reason enough to pursue politics of interdependence and to seek closer relations with Europe.

When Britain applied to join the EEC in the summer of 1961, it was nonetheless with the ambition to lead within the EEC and to secure the UK’s special position in world affairs. By joining the EEC, they hoped to shape it according to British interests, while maintaining the special relations with both the US and the Commonwealth. In the end, it was the three-circle concept and Britain’s traditional strife for leadership which the French President, Charles de Gaulle, invoked to portray the UK as ill-prepared to accept the conditions of EEC membership. He rejected Britain’s applications to the EEC twice, in 1963 and 1967.

Since the UK joined the EEC in 1973, the British people have voted twice on their continued membership, ultimately deciding to leave in 2016. The idea that an independent and sovereign Britain could take on a leading role in global affairs has been a dominant narrative in the context of the Brexit referendum and its aftermath. It drew both on the collective memory of Britain’s imperial past an on the notion that, amongst the European powers, Britain alone had been steadfast against enemy invasion in the Second World War. As Anne Deighton has argued, the long roots of Brexit thus seem to lie deep in Britain’s an ‘imperial cultural residue’ and claim to political leadership that has expressed itself in a reluctance about European integration.

As Burnham himself has now declared, the decade since the referendum has, in fact, shown that Britain does not have the power to ‘go it alone’. The economic effects of Brexit are severe, aggravated by the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. While the UK has been able to sign a number of free trade deals since Brexit, their effect seems unable to offset the overall negative economic impact of Brexit. The relationship with the EU that had been poisoned by the Brexit decision has only slowly been rebuilt under successive governments’ attempts to find frameworks for a more productive relationship, such as the  Windsor Framework during Rishi Sunak’s premiership in 2023 or the Labour Government’s current determination to ‘reset’ the UK-EU relations.

It is time for Britain to get out of the habit of promising leadership on all fronts. It should not seek to play a special role in Europe as an objective in re-negotiating the post-Brexit relationship. Instead, British decision-makers should offer British collaboration as a team player in a club of democracies with shared values. Even if EU re-entry remains off the table, this would be a far more fruitful position to adopt if the ambition to reset the relationship with the EU is to be pursued in earnest.


 

About the author

Dr Larissa Kraft is Robert McIntosh Applied History & Policy Visiting Fellow at the Institute of Historical Research. She is currently developing a series of engagement events based on her University of Glasgow doctoral thesis on ‘Representations of the Past in Political Discourse: Comparing Britain, France and West Germany During the First British Application to the European Economic Community’.

  • Papers by author

  • The theme

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Sign up to receive announcements on events, the latest research and more!

To complete the subscription process, please click the link in the email we just sent you.

We will never send spam and you can unsubscribe any time.

About Us


H&P is based at the Institute of Historical Research, Senate House, University of London.

We are the only project in the UK providing access to an international network of more than 500 historians with a broad range of expertise. H&P offers a range of resources for historians, policy makers and journalists.